FRA Certification Helpline: (216) 694-0240

Fallout from Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena’s threatening remarks to a closed-door meeting of 900 shippers caught on video continues to send shockwaves through the railroad industry and could possibly derail the proposed $85 billion merger with Norfolk Southern.

The Surface Transportation Board, the federal agency with oversight of railroad mergers, wrote: “Retaliation, whether perceived or actual, can seriously undermine the integrity of the Board’s processes. Any evidence of retaliation in this proceeding will be considered by the Board, and evidence of retaliation, or the threat of retaliation, may affect how the Board proceeds…”

In a November 12 article, national news magazine The American Prospect detailed how the railroad went to great lengths to conceal the damning video. The article also touches on why the vast majority of rail labor — unions representing 70 percent of what would be the combined unionized workforce, including BLET— oppose the acquisition of NS by UP.

BLET National President Mark Wallace is quoted in the article explaining why Vena’s claim of granting a “jobs for life” guarantee is a hollow promise. “What some people see as a gold standard is actually fool’s gold,” said Wallace. “Unless you have it in writing what your location is going to be, that you’re going to be [practicing the same] craft, and that your income is protected, then none of that matters to me — it doesn’t matter to our members.”

Read the article in its entirety here.

Release of the Vena video also prompted Wisconsin Senator Tammy Baldwin to renew her call for the Surface Transportation Board to reject the merger. “We can see for ourselves that Union Pacific’s CEO is openly talking about retaliating against shippers who are rightfully concerned that more consolidation in Class I rail will lead to worse service and higher costs for businesses, farmers, and families. That’s no laughing matter to my constituents,” she said in a news release. “I’m calling on the Surface Transportation Board to reject a megamerger that will hurt our Made in Wisconsin economy.”

After trying to conceal the damning video, UP was forced to make it public last week under pressure from the STB. Vena said: “[If the merger doesn’t happen], Union Pacific will still be there. And if I stick around, which I probably will, I’ll probably increase everybody’s rates that said they didn’t want a seamless railroad by 3 or 4 extra percent to teach you a lesson.”

You can watch the video here and judge for yourself.